51 guys were introduced by Chaos Men in 2018 and 48 of those guys returned for a 2nd or more scenes.
The 3 guys who did not return were Zuko, Hammond & Ryan Tone.
Of the 48 guys who returned, 28 only did an oral scene – Barney, Warren, Tyger, Boyd, Maurice, Constantine, Cypher, Adam Gomez, Armin, Johnson, Marty, Justin Derra, Jake Hart, Johnny Dees, Archer, Kurt Tucker, Owyn, Laszlo, Gordon, Volker, Kane Haney, Beckett, Marcel, Maxi, Wynn, Steve Strongarm, Lucas Miller and Wheeler.
And, the 20 guys who returned for a hardcore scene were Nathan Cruise, Draven, Dani deMuse, Damien Reign, JJ Smitts, Milan, Bentley Layne, Mason Lear, Lucas Leon, Wills, Matthew West, Declan, Michael Shores, Espen, Carter Sloan, Aidan Anthony, Blaze Burton, Ricky Roberts, Davos and Terry.
